Fort Myers Pizza

Grandma Penny’s Pizza, Fort Myers pizza restaurant offers a truly Italian experience using centuries-old techniques and authentic handmade ingredients! Offering NY Style Brick Oven Pizzas, Pasta Dinners, Fresh Subs, Salads, Calzones, Stromboli, Beer, Wine, and more!

Located at the former Amore Brick Oven Pizza location, we serve oven-fresh creations brimming with the cheesy and tangy goodness people have come to love, plus a few more flavors to spice things up! Our signature pizza sauce, which we have perfected using the finest ingredients and spices, is sure to add delight to every diner’s pizza experience.

Sharing hearty laughter and lively conversations over freshly baked pizza with loved ones sounds great after a long, stressful day at work. Be it a simple family dinner or a much-awaited weekend get-together with friends, our Fort Myers pizza restaurant is the place to be for good food to make your night-out more wonderful!

Fort Myers Pizza Restaurant

Dine in our restaurant and enjoy our pizzas. If you’re craving Italian food, we also serve Italian dishes that will satisfy your cravings. Browse through our website for more information about us and what we have in store for you! We look forward to serving you.

Our dining room caters to groups, teams, families, and individuals featuring bar seating and large high definition TVs that will certainly be on and showing your favorite team!

Open Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Sunday from 12pm – 8pm. Friday & Saturday 12pm – 9pm. Closed Monday.

“You’re better than that, come join the family!”

Grandma Penny


What people


4353 Hancock Bridge Pkwy
North Fort Myers, FL 33903

Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday  from 12pm – 8pm

Friday 12pm – 9pm.

Saturday & Sunday from 3pm – 8pm.

Closed Monday.


2020 Grandma Pennys Pizza. All Rights Reserved.